SAVE VS PODCAST
A Beholder podcast host at its ornate desk in a cobwebbed crypt, torchlight flickering over skulls and grimoires

The Grimoire / Episode 3

Ep. 3 Sep 2, 2026 49:10

Non-Fantasy TTRPG Genres

What happens when you drag your TTRPG group into sci-fi, horror, western, or superhero territory?

Quest Summary

Fantasy gets all the love at the table — but what happens when you drag your TTRPG group into sci-fi, horror, western, or superhero territory? The crew discusses the hardest non-fantasy genres to actually run, and argues about why some genres that sound easy on paper aren’t.

Bill and Jon — two GMs with old school RPG roots — break down what makes sci-fi, horror, western, and superhero campaigns uniquely difficult to prep and run: tone control, power-levels, genre-savvy players, and the pacing traps specific to each setting.

“If you’ve ever tried to run a horror one-shot that wasn’t scary, a supers game that didn’t feel all that super, or a western that turned into non-stop gunfights — then this one’s for you.”

— Save Vs Podcast

Scenarios & Topics

  • Sci-Fi

  • Horror

  • Western

  • Superhero